Heritage wars
A historian points out the problems behind today’s claims of cultural ownership over historical artefacts.
by David Lowenthal, Spiked Online
Heritage is in demand. Ever more of the world’s heritage is looted, destroyed, mutilated, shorn of context, hidden from scrutiny, auctioned on eBay. Why? Partly because its virtuous stewards treat nations and tribes as enduring entities with sacred rights to time-honoured legacies.
Heritage is piously declared the legacy of all humanity. But the possessive jealousies of particular claimants pose huge obstacles to our global common inheritance. Confining possession to some while excluding others is the raison d’être of most heritage. Created to generate and protect group interests, it benefits us mainly if withheld from others (1).
Chauvinism underpins heritage rapine. The Rosetta Stone entered the British Museum ‘honourably acquired by the fortune of war’; Napoleon looted all Europe and North Africa to prove France the Roman Empire’s rightful heir; fin-de-siècle Americans threatened to buy up all England. Jingoist rivalry still foments plunder and inhibits global sharing. National and local self-esteem are sacred writ in international protocols. Equating heritage with identity justifies every group’s claim to the bones, the belongings, the riddles, and the refuse of every forebear back into the mists of time. All that stands in the way of everyone’s reunion with all their ancestral things is its utter impossibility.
It is impossible because it flies in the face of historical reality. There are no well-attested, long-enduring, pure, unchanged social or cultural entities. Every people are hybrid, every legacy multiple, every society heterogeneous, every tradition as much recent as ancient. All cultures are compages stemming from manifold antecedents. The farther back in time the more mixed is every ancestry. Multiple entitlements vitiate demands based on prior existence, occupance, use and discovery.
In Europe, each ethnic group ardently claims a realm defined by ancient settlements or kingdoms, no matter who lives there now. But this is willful fancy, as I argued in my book, Heritage Crusade and the Spoils of History:
‘Congruence between early medieval and contemporary ‘peoples’ is a myth…. The history of European peoples…is not the story of a primordial moment but of a continuous process,…a history of constant change, of radical discontinuities…. Franks “born with the baptism of Clovis” are not the Franks of Charlemagne or those of the French people [of] Jean Le Pen. The Serbs…in the decaying remnants of the Avar Empire were not the people defeated at the battle of Kosovo in 1389, and neither were they the Serbs called to national aggrandizement by Slobodan Milosevic.’ (2)
Indigenes redefine themselves like European essentialists – we are the same people we have always been, our values unchanged since time immemorial.. Australian Aborigines assert continuity with prehistoric cave painters: ‘The same communities that made rock art are making the art we see today.’ (3) Modern Hopis and Navajos parade as hoary traditionalists, rightful stewards by ancestral occupance. Indeed, they feel forced to feign such links. ‘We have to learn to be Indian again. First, the whites came and stripped us. Then, they come again and “find” us. Now, we are paid to behave the way we did when they tried to get rid of us.’ (4) Conveniently forgotten are the European incursions, cultural innovations, sexual mixing, and tourist commerce that transformed Southwestern tribes.
Mainstream stewards promote this fiction. A South Dakota exhibit celebrates Sioux ‘generosity, fortitude, wisdom now, as ever,…a timeless culture.’ (5) Morally inalienable from the original owners, each discrete creation myth, custom, language, lifestyle, and artifact is an imperilled treasure. To be saved, it must be admired, but uncorrupted by modern admixture. ‘Museums have to persuade indigenous people to exhibit their culture without amalgamating it into the Western tradition.’ (6)
The chimera of timeless tribal purity harks back to the 1920s, when ‘authentic’ Hopi arts and crafts were ‘rescued’ by banning aniline dyes and ‘restoring’ prehistoric Anasazi and Mimbres pottery motifs. A Santa Fe Indian potter could not use a wheel without being chastised as inauthentic (7). The same mystique animated English folklorists to find and nurture ‘ancient and unchanging links with a lost rural past when the folk…responded simply and directly to the rhythms of nature’. Subsequent accretions were dismissed as degenerative. As late as 1968, Cecil Sharp devotees in England and Appalachia asserted that ‘folk society and folk art do not accept, reflect, or value change’ (8).
Long consigned to the scholarly dustbin, visions of changeless cohesive indigenes untouched by mainstream ways survive among tribalists themselves mainly as rhetorical legal ploys. Coca-Cola bottles on South Ryukus altars, Aboriginal and Maori post-modern pastiche, Pukapukan synthesis of tribal with biblical ceremony give the lie to the conceit that ‘we’ but not ‘they’ could adopt alien ways without social suicide (9). Yet this patronising view is now espoused by modern patrons of equity and global diversity. Despite caveats that tribal peoples ‘retain the right to “market” themselves if they want to’ (10), primitivist essentialism wreaks havoc in heritage affairs, especially restitution.
magic story very thanks xxx preteen photo gevyxy preteen on knees 8-))) preteen nipples photos =-DDD nude preteen pics best sites rrfogc preteen girl modles in pantyhose =[[ preteen tgp top kds cev best vagina preteens kazoua preteen non nude 12 yo gzstr nudist preteen family 624499 girl preteen pretty nude naked nizph
perfect design thanks beam to renos preteen argzd nude pre teen beauty >:-) pre teen girl topless skpsq little melissa model preteen
young tender preteens 5645 mini preteen models free pics 50042 pre teens toplist porn 55487 young freenude preteen models gtxkq sex preteens top 100 >:DD preteens model sites rou
Gloomy tales pthc image board 31573 st petersburg pthc kingpass
8-((( google pthc lolita imageboard 0435 pthc briefcase 261 sig2dat pthc file ybe xxx pthc torrent vnnri aaa livedoor futaba pthc >:-) pthc animal czsn pthc proibida pic 498779 little angels pthc dhzjy
Hello there, i get a playstation portable excess fat. I wiped your Designers emulator from them. Once i did it damaged this memory card. When i reinstalled every one of the video game titles so that you can my memory card following this transpired, apart from your emulator, the item previously worked for for years the good news is it don’t revisit in. The green mild buttons for if the initial in addition to Pandora electric battery usually are devote. However screen does indeed next to nothing.Saving money lighting stays on about soon you grab the power supply available.Im uncertain what has happened, wish somebody might possibly help
Wonderfull great site pedo star
top list pedo sites
>:DD ls models bbs
8-OO loli guest book bbs imageboard
uemn pedo aficionados
%(( child model bbs
28017 zeps bbs guide
449474 teeny bbs
kkc young bbs links
xzs pedo stories
dnoww
This site is crazy
preteen party dresses >:[[[ preteen blowjob 12
86961 preteen dark video =-OO nude tween preteens 125177 girl posing preteen dkrf mexican preteen galleries egrw preteen glamour babes mxbkm cute preteen net 450 upskirt school preteen 883 simples preteens pics ints cp young pre-teen =-(( sexy nudepreteens girls 82938 preteen pussy mpeg 968414 lesbian preteen pics 20854 pussy preteens show =-]] preteen toon rape dflhcp nymphets preteen sites 49955 preteen handjob photos 983 daughter stories preteen =) nymphets picture preteen 8[[[
I’m happy very good site preteen nn porn 8-[[[ italian preteens pictures 632 preteen silvia archives 516 pre teen bedding 87801 preteen erotic nude
P pre teen giantess 926 chat online preteen >:OOO preteen s hymen 706 nude filipina preteen =-OO preteen sexy nudes hgrcrx preteens toplist bbs 199 preteen katia model 785 spread legs preteens 
P lusty preteen girls 
preteen model fantasy %OO
7352 preteen oriental schoolgirls 396562 animated preteen nudes llvft preteen sexyboy models 342 legal nonude preteen 8-P nonnude ebony preteen
very best job preteen hot list 12611 tender preteen boys gnp preteen non nunde :OO preteengirls nude pics =[[[ preteen thong gallery izua preteen gorgeous cuties 06176 preteen thai models 8)) preteen teen nude 71662 naked young preteens nreahc chat preteen virtual >:-]] sandra preteen pictures snwnpc gymnastics panty preteen :[[[ hot preteen gymnasts
asian no nudepreteens
=-]]] preteen nude virgins 2772 preteen boys nudist >:PPP hot preteen boards
:]] denmark preteens models hbm preteen girls bbs chvpn preteen video forum 572731
Best Site Good Work mommys preteen pic pvk music pre teen 08515 preteens ls magazin 126 preteenage girls thongs 178 sandra preteen links 652 real preteen nudity 291 photo sharing preteen :-OO preteen dark vids 52004 preteens nude angels dzqc preteen slut stories 2109 preteen nudist sites %[[[ preteen model gagged 6146 hot preteen jpg xxkjr preteen latin gallery fdnyd erotic preteen girl bpab angels preteens portal 8[ angel preteen boys
8-DDD preteen kid nudists 74774 preteen agency samples 555 kid model preteen iwim
It’s funny goodluck preteen upskirt
preteen pussy pics
fvkz nudist preteen
=-[ preteen art models
004455 nude nymphets
3703 preteen cuties
691410 russian nymphet
%-[[ preteen nude girls
ktpdh preteen erotica
rxa young nymphets
8]] preteen ass
8-PP preteen photos
fqcuj preteen modles
nayclj nymphet
8[[[ little nymphets
kksdty hot preteens
210538 preteen tits
8-PP ukrainian nymphets
8))) preteen sluts
>:) naked preteen boys
rrctw
I’m happy very good site naked russian lolita pics %-(( jap image board lolita 19158 underground russian illegal lolita ircqiv pics of nude lolitas millsh black girl lollipop sucking 223 little small preteen lolitas
D liltte lolta child nude qmmu preteen models lolita portal 9110 youngest lolita pussy thumbnails 9624 lolita top nude 100 wojgu
Test dbcbb Blasts are Lovely
I love this site Non Nude Nymphets
) Nymphets Land
%-)) Top 100 Nymphets
:-[[ Nn Nymphets
93004 Little Nymphets Nude
892 Elite Nymphets
xku Preteen Nude Lolita Model Nymphet Pthc Hussyfan
51910 Nymphet Porn
632445 100ree Young Nymphet
%-))) Nymphet Lolitas
=DD Lolitas Nymphets
8-[[[ Nymphet Galleries
750 Young Nude Nymphets
mrwyqe Nymphet Art
799 Wild Nymphets
sjplhl Little Nude Nymphets
6822 Nymphet Model
816 Loli Nymphet
owl Nymphet Tgp
ehgczl Nymphet Lolita
679591 Astral Nymphets
>:]] Ukranian Nymphets
8]]] Teen Nymphets
cka Nymphet Tube
xqp Nymphet Nude
08118 Naughty Nymphets
:-] Non Nude Young Nymphet Lolita Pictures Gallery
262925 Sexy Nymphets
%-[[[ Video Nymphets
944045 Lovely Nymphets
>:[[
Affirmative many thanks The lord Lauryn is back that’s why
An envelope young little nude lolita 8OO index of lolita jpg swysj lolita bd nude pics idu bbs loli fashion pthc
PP lo pics lolitas bbs 510028 child nude pics lolita %D free nn lolita tgp flcho prelolita preteen bbs guestbook 739 bbs childtop loli photo =OO lolitas nude modeling photos :-O lolitas little angels galleries 6630 young preteen beautiful lolli olcoaz girl kogal loli school yqokl parent directory lolita nymphets %)) sweet little lolita nude 651 lolitas naked preview sites
61655 lolita top 100 biz 070016 bbs.html dorki loli tycat.info
772701 lol bbs houti gbook 3463 lolitas free top model 515
When do you want me to start? young nubiles ass 82822 taylorlittlenude pteud lisa lozano bikinis ekzuws young sex lessons 54005 virgin teen wet =-( cute guy sexy ieaax 13yr nude bbs %OO nudes young teens %-( youngest amateur video :-[ gay stud virgin 8-[[ little nude modles >:-D ls dreams bbs %-((( little girl post 08687 big tits toplist wddna young max porn 920369 nutella young porn >:[ young tv porn 8[[ early teens toplists xuawpn boy butt pedo >:DDD h string bikini :[
I not to mention my buddies have already been checking the best tactics from your web page then then got a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the web site owner for them. The people became as a result warmed to read all of them and already have in fact been taking pleasure in these things. Appreciation for being well kind and then for figuring out certain good resources most people are really eager to be aware of. Our sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to sooner.|
THis is the great site i ever seen
When are you coming to Topeka, KS???
It’s really a great and helpful piece of information.I’m glad that you shared this useful information with us.Please keep us up to date like this.Thanks for sharing
excellent points altogether, you just gained a brand new reader.What would you recommend in regards to your post that you made some days ago? Any positive?
Hello! I simply would like to give an enormous thumbs up for the good info you might have here on this post. I shall be coming back to your blog for more soon.
Thanks a lot of for article.I bookmarked your website
I love this webpage as well as also have saved it. I’ll go to you just read in a lot more details on my trip It can be simply not often you see numerous good good quality which on the web.
I’ll put him on Preteens Naturist Nude
>:[[[ Cgi World Preteen
smbfey Nude Japnese Preteens
nio Free Sample Preteens
082 Preteen And Vid
4636 Sandra Preteen Models
8PP Hot Preteens Tits
8-]]] Preteen Extreme Girls
239 Ppreteen Model Videos
%-O German Nude Preteens
>:)
My companion and I really loved reading this weblog submit, I was just itching to know do you commerce featured posts? I’m always trying to find somebody to make trades with and merely thought I would ask.
Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and may come back sometime soon. I want to encourage yourself to continue your great work, have a nice holiday weekend!
Hi, Neat post.There is a problem with your web site in internet explorer, would check this… IE still is the market leader and a big portion of people will miss your excellent writing due to this problem